Judging

Find out how judges are selected.

Choosing the judges

Judges are selected from the ranks of former/retired newspaper and magazine journalists and editors, non-conflicted editors and journalists (such as from other countries), freelancers, academics, public relations executives and broadcasters. Where possible, judging panels of two and three people are selected, especially for the major awards. The selection process tries to ensure there is regional representation. The intention is also to freshen up the judging line-up with an injection of some new faces each year. Judges should not have direct ties with any newspaper or publishing group although we do allow freelancers to judge in a category they are not likely to enter.

Judging procedure

Judges will numerically score all entries assigned to them based on a set of scoring criteria provided by the Newspaper Publishers’ Association. Scoring criteria may be up-weighted or down-weighted, are totalled for each entry and an average calculated across all judges. Judges will be aware of only the results in their category.

Judges' reward

Judges are not paid other than sometimes with a gift of modest value, and in the main centres, occasionally a judges' lunch. Most say they do it for the love of journalism and the honour of being asked to be a judge.

Selection timeframe

Judges are selected between November and January. All judges are contacted beforehand and asked if they are prepared to take on the workload, and meet the various criteria including judging deadline.

2017 judges

View the high-calibre list of journalists selected to judge the entries in the 2017 Canon Media Awards.  

Inquiries

Email: canonmediaawards@npa.co.nz 
Phone: Jane Phare, NPA Awards Director, jane.phare@npa.co.nz or phone 021 500 995 or Rick Neville, NPA Editorial Director, phone 021 279 6447.

Contact us

Let us know how we can help and we'll get back to you as soon as we can.

Get in touch

News updates

Sign up to receive updates from the Newspaper Publishers' Association.

Sign up